T O P I C R E V I E W |
James_Hetfield2 | Zen lands have been out for a few years now. Doing a little market research, basically want to know what your favorite and least favorite of each basic land type are from an art perspective. Thanks in advance for participation! Here are some links to the art. 4 Forest #246 John Avon 0 Forest #247 Jung Park 0 Forest #248 Veronique Meignaud -2 Forest #249 Vincent Proce -1 Island #234 John Avon 3 Island #235 Jung Park 1 Island #236 Veronique Meignaud -1 Island #237 Vincent Proce 4 Plains #230 John Avon -1 Plains #231 Jung Park -1 Plains #232 Veronique Meignaud -1 Plains #233 Vincent Proce 3 Mountain #242 John Avon 1 Mountain #243 Jung Park 2 Mountain #244 Veronique Meignaud -5 Mountain #245 Vincent Proce 4 Swamp #238 John Avon -4 Swamp #239 Jung Park 2 Swamp #240 Veronique Meignaud -3 Swamp #241 Vincent Proce
[Edited 3 times, lastly by James_Hetfield2 on November 27, 2012] |
James_Hetfield2 | Forests Favorite: #246 Least Favorite: #249 Islands Favorite: #235 Least Favorite: #236 Plains Favorite: #230 Least Favorite: #231 Mountains Favorite: #242 Least Favorite: #245 Swamps Favorite: #238 Least Favorite: #239
[Edited 1 times, lastly by James_Hetfield2 on November 25, 2012] |
AlmostGrown | Favorite forest: 247 Least favorite forest: 248Favorite island: 237 least favorite island: 234 favorite plains: 233 least favorite plains: 230 Favorite mountain: 243 Least favorite mountain: 245 Favorite swamp: 238 least favorite swamp: 240 __________________ Check out the greatest store in Southeastern Pennsylvania: Stomping Grounds Games & Hobbies! www.sggamesandhobbies.com Serra Angel Count: 1171 Nightmare Count: 253 DCI Judge Level 1 PlasteredDragon - Gone but not forgotten
|
keywacat | Would you set this up by artist name? It will make going through it much faster. |
Undomian | Forests: Favorite: #247 Least favorite: #248Islands: Favorite: #235 Least favorite: #236 Plains: Favorite: #231 Least favorite: #230 Mountains: Favorite: #245 Least favorite: #244 Swamps: Favorite: #238 Least favorite: #239 |
James_Hetfield2 | quote: Originally posted by keywacat: Would you set this up by artist name? It will make going through it much faster.
I added the artist names to the links if that helps. |
wayne | Forests Favorite: Avon Least Favorite: Proce Islands Favorite: Meignaud Least Favorite: Proce Plains Favorite: Avon Least Favorite: Meignaud Mountains Favorite: Avon Least Favorite: Proce Swamps Favorite: Meignaud Least Favorite: Proce
|
Zeckk | Favorites - Meignaud and Avon for every land type except plains (Meignaud's plains art is just awful, especially in foil). Least favorites - Jung Park Swamp (looks like 2 turd piles) Jung Park Island (looks like a blue mountain) Favorite foil -
John Avon Forest. I routinely get complimented on those whenever I get to play with them in a tourney.
|
MeddlingMage | Forests: Favorite: #248 Least favorite: #249Islands: Favorite: #236 Least favorite: #237 Plains: Favorite: #230 Least favorite: #233 Mountains: Favorite: #242 Least favorite: #244 Swamps: Favorite: #240 Least favorite: #241 ~MM __________________ Blah, blah, blah werewolf. Smackity-smack not a werewolf. Suspicious of this fruit loop. My vote this round will be for Player X.New keeper of the Logout button
|
FleeceItOut | favorites are mostly split between avon and meignaud while least favorites being a split of park and proce |
choco man | WHAT!?! No love for the Proce bowl island? My favorites are the Plains. Avon and Meignaud |
Zeckk | quote: Originally posted by choco man: WHAT!?!No love for the Proce bowl island? My favorites are the Plains. Avon and Meignaud
Proce island is a cool premise, but the color palette just doesn't pop, especially on foils. Avon island foils are things of beauty. |
Mr.C | Plains none, all of them are ugly Island 235 Swamp see plains Mountain 244 Forest 248 |
stab107 | I really like: Forest #246 John Avon Island #234 John Avon Island #235 Jung Park Island #236 Veronique Meignaud Island #237 Vincent Proce Plains #230 John Avon Mountain #244 Veronique Meignaud Swamp #238 John AvonI don't really care for: Forest #247 Jung Park Plains #231 Jung Park Mountain #245 Vincent Proce Swamp #239 Jung Park
[Edited 1 times, lastly by stab107 on November 25, 2012] |
PortlisX | Meignaud Mountain is my favorite of them all, and Proce Mountain is my least favorite of them all. |
Aznopium | My favorite artist of these is Meignaud, so all the zendikar basics i want to use are by her.. Forest: #249 Vincent Proce (just a cooler forest than Meignaud in this case)
Island: #236 Veronique Meignaud Plains: #230 John Avon (best one of the bunch) Mountain #244 Veronique Meignaud (try to find these in foil, i know someone is buying these puppies out everyhwere!) Swamp #240 Veronique Meignaud (dont really like any of them) Worst ones IMHO Mountain Proce Mountain Park Forest Park Plains Proce Swamp Proce
[Edited 1 times, lastly by Aznopium on November 26, 2012]
|
James_Hetfield2 | I updated the counts with +1 for like, -1 for dislike. If you voted for more than one, I may not have counted your vote (did my best to decipher). edit: Plains 233 and Mountain 244 have definitely grown on me.
[Edited 1 times, lastly by James_Hetfield2 on November 27, 2012] |
ravidell | Forest 248 Island 236 Plains 234 Mountain 244 Swamp 240So..... Veronique Meignaud by far, did not like her plains as much as Park. And for the record (Avon fans may not want to read on...) I didn't like any of Avons art for the the lands in this set. |
daner | I liked all of Meignuad's artwork. I actually liked Proce's mountain, I use them instead of Meignaud's. I really think Avon gets praise on his name alone for these lands. While I wont say they are all the worst, some of Park's are awful, I will say none of Avon's ever impressed me. |
Marvin Austria | Best Forest: John Avon Worst Forest: ProceBest Island: Proce Worst Island by far: Jung Park Best Mountain: Meignaud Worst Mountain: Proce Best Plains: John Avon Worst Plains: Jung Park Best Swamp: John Avon Worst Swamp: Meignard Please people keep posting your favourites!! -M
|
keywacat | Favorites: Swamp: J. Park (although my set of Zendikar swamps are actually from V. Meignaud) Island: V. Meignaud Forest: V. Meignaud Mountain: V. Meignaud Plains: V. ProceLeast Favorites: Swamp: V. Proce Island: J. Park Forest: J. Park Mountain: J. Park Plains: J. Park This feels unfortunate as most of J. Park's other works I greatly enjoy. The Forest in Avacyn Restored is perfect, in Zendikar he either didn't get a good feel for it or was overshadowed by stiffer competition.
[Edited 1 times, lastly by keywacat on December 16, 2012] |
Caramel | + are favorites, - are least liked: +248 -246 +236 -235 +232 -230 +244 -242、 +240 -239
[Edited 1 times, lastly by Caramel on December 16, 2012] |
xilla001 | Forest +248 -246Island +236 -237 Plains +231 -230 Mountain +244 -243 Swamp +240 -238 Best arts 1. Plains 231 2. Swamp 240 Normaly Avon is my favourite artist, but I don't like his arts on Zen lands. |
Dimh | This was harder than I expected, as I only use Unglued now. + Forest #249 Vincent Proce - Forest #247 Jung Park + Island #237 Vincent Proce - Island #234 John Avon + Plains #231 Jung Park - Plains #232 Veronique Meignaud + Mountain #245 Vincent Proce - Mountain #243 Jung Park + Swamp #240 Veronique Meignaud - Swamp #241 Vincent Proce
|
Marvin Austria | correct me if Im wrong: Stand: 17.12.2012 2 Forest #246 John Avon -2 Forest #247 Jung Park 4 Forest #248 Veronique Meignaud -1 Forest #249 Vincent Proce -2 Island #234 John Avon 1 Island #235 Jung Park 5 Island #236 Veronique Meignaud -3 Island #237 Vincent Proce 2 Plains #230 John Avon -0 Plains #231 Jung Park 0 Plains #232 Veronique Meignaud 0 Plains #233 Vincent Proce 2 Mountain #242 John Avon -1 Mountain #243 Jung Park 6 Mountain #244 Veronique Meignaud -5 Mountain #245 Vincent Proce 3 Swamp #238 John Avon -4 Swamp #239 Jung Park 6 Swamp #240 Veronique Meignaud -5 Swamp #241 Vincent Proce Give me your opinions, Im also very interested in this survey =)
Some preferable lands are already getting noticeable, keep your opinion posting to have a better overview on this one!
[Edited 1 times, lastly by Marvin Austria on December 17, 2012]
|